Italy’s data protection authority has fined Meta €805 million (about 1.21 trillion won) for operating a feature that accessed users’ smartphone photo libraries without their consent.
▶ The Italian Data Protection Authority fined Meta Platforms Ireland €805 million (about 1.21 trillion won).
▶ The penalty was imposed because the Facebook app for Android recommended photos and videos from users’ photo libraries for posts without obtaining specific consent.
▶ It is the largest fine ever issued by Italy’s data protection authority.

On the 14th local time, the Italian Data Protection Authority (Garante) announced that Meta Platforms Ireland had violated privacy laws by operating a photo and video recommendation feature in the Facebook app for Android. The fine is the largest ever imposed by the authority.
The feature at issue, “Camera Roll Suggestions While Browsing Facebook,” recommends photos and videos saved in a user’s smartphone photo library for addition to posts while the user is on Facebook.
The authority has investigated the feature’s data-processing practices since 2025. Its investigation found that Facebook requested access to a smartphone’s photo library just once for the app as a whole. The same permission was used for services with different purposes, including letting users select photos to post and recommending content stored in their photo libraries.
The authority also said the notice shown before the permission request was not specific enough. As a result, users could not readily understand that they were authorizing the photo and video recommendation feature.
The authority noted that granting access to an entire photo library could allow the app to read a wide range of photos stored on a device. It also said that users and regulators would find it difficult to determine what information was actually being used.
Italy’s data protection authority concluded that the feature violated Italian law implementing the European Union’s ePrivacy Directive. The relevant rules require valid consent before accessing information stored on a user’s device.
The authority said Facebook did not adequately explain the purpose of each individual feature when requesting access to users’ photo libraries. It found that blanket permission for the app as a whole did not satisfy the consent requirements for the photo and video recommendation feature.
The enforcement action concerned access to photo libraries and the process for obtaining user consent. The authority’s announcement did not say that photos or videos had been transferred outside the device or used to train AI.
During the investigation, Meta challenged the Italian authority’s jurisdiction. The company argued that the case should be handled by Ireland’s data protection authority because its European operations are managed by an entity based in Ireland.
The European Union’s General Data Protection Regulation provides for a “one-stop-shop” system, under which the supervisory authority in the country where a company has its main establishment plays the lead role in cases involving businesses operating in multiple member states.
Italy’s data protection authority rejected Meta’s argument, saying the system does not apply to the ePrivacy rules relevant to this case.
The authority ordered Meta to obtain separate consent for the photo and video recommendation feature within 60 days. Meta must clearly explain to users the feature’s purpose, its access to smartphone photo libraries, and how to disable it.
The feature must also be turned off by default. The same measures will apply to users who have already granted access to their photo libraries.
Meta did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the decision. It can appeal the administrative ruling.