A driverless robotaxi is already operating on U.S. roads
Zoox and Tesla have taken different approaches to bringing their vehicles onto public roads
Safety systems for handling breakdowns, crashes and emergencies are key
[Sol News Reporter Lee Seung-hoon] When people think of a car, the first things that come to mind are the steering wheel and pedals. For more than 100 years, cars have been represented by the image of a driver sitting facing forward, steering and controlling the speed. Now, efforts are underway to remove all of those familiar controls.
How would cars change if the driver’s seat disappeared? Could people leave driving entirely behind? Above all, would passengers feel safe getting into a car without a steering wheel or brake pedal? This series began with those questions. It looks at driverless cars already on the road, laws and safety standards still built around human drivers, and the technologies being developed to address crashes and breakdowns.

If a car can drive itself, does it need a steering wheel for a person? Must it also have an accelerator and brake pedal? The passenger seats could occupy the space left by the driver’s seat, and the interior could be arranged like a small living room.
That once seemed like little more than a vision of future cars. Now it can be seen on U.S. roads. Cars without steering wheels or pedals are carrying passengers. Autonomous driving technology, which began with a human driver ready to take over in an emergency, is moving into a new phase in which the car does not provide driving controls at all.
The fact that a car can be made without a steering wheel is not the same as saying that everyone can use it safely. Unexpected situations arise constantly on the road. Traffic lights can fail, or construction can shift lanes. Police may also direct a vehicle to move.
How would a car without a steering wheel respond? If it failed to stop when no passenger could press the brake, who would intervene? These are among the problems automakers and regulators must solve.
◆ The driver’s seat is beginning to disappear from cars

The robotaxi developed by Amazon subsidiary Zoox looks different from an ordinary passenger car. It has no distinction between a driver’s seat and a front passenger seat; instead, passengers sit facing one another. The vehicle has no steering wheel or pedals and can travel in either direction.
It breaks with the conventional car design in which the driver must sit facing forward. Passengers do not take part in driving as the vehicle travels to its destination. Sensors installed in the vehicle, including cameras, lidar and radar, detect the surrounding environment, while the autonomous driving system determines the route and speed.
On July 30, the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) announced a temporary exemption from safety standards for Zoox robotaxis. It exempted the vehicles from some provisions of eight existing vehicle safety standards and allowed commercial operation. The exemption runs through July 2028 and applies to up to 2,500 vehicles per year.
Tesla has also put a car without a steering wheel into operation. The Cybercab, first unveiled in 2024, is a self-driving vehicle designed to carry two people. It has no steering wheel, accelerator or brake pedals, or conventional side mirrors. Tesla began operating Cybercabs in Austin, Texas, in September. Passengers summon a vehicle, which then takes them to their destination.
Both companies aim to provide transportation that does not require a human driver. But they have taken different paths onto public roads. Zoox received exemptions from some existing safety standards, while Tesla certified on its own that the Cybercab meets the standards applicable to it. U.S. regulators have opened an investigation into Tesla’s certification approach. The technical question of whether a car can be built without a steering wheel has thus become a legal one: how should automotive safety standards apply?
◆ Harder than removing the steering wheel

Removing a steering wheel from a car is not particularly complicated. With electronic steering and braking systems, a car’s direction and speed can be controlled without a person physically operating mechanical controls. The challenge is making sure the car moves safely.
In a human-driven car, the driver checks road conditions, steers and applies the brakes. In a car without a steering wheel, the autonomous driving system performs these functions. Sensors that detect the environment, computers that make decisions and controls that move the vehicle must all work together.
The autonomous driving system analyzes camera images and sensor data to identify lanes, pedestrians, other vehicles and obstacles. It then calculates a route and issues steering, acceleration and braking commands. So far, this is not very different from conventional autonomous driving technology. The difference becomes apparent when the system does not work properly.
In a car with a steering wheel, a person can take over in certain situations. Passengers in a car without a steering wheel cannot intervene in the same way. Separate safeguards and response procedures are needed to address system failures. In particular, a vehicle without a driver must be able to assess risks and bring itself to a safe state. If it cannot continue operating, it must slow down and stop.
Further action may be needed if the vehicle stops in a dangerous location. The central challenge in developing cars without steering wheels is not simply replacing human driving with a machine. It is building a system that can safely manage situations in which no person can intervene.
◆ U.S. law still assumes the presence of a brake pedal

Even if a car can operate technically, it must meet legal requirements to drive on public roads. U.S. Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards have long been based on vehicles driven by people. Many provisions assume that a driver operates the brakes, turns the steering wheel and checks behind the vehicle using mirrors.
Brake requirements are one example. Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard No. 135 governs braking systems for light vehicles. Existing rules include requirements related to brake controls operated by hand or foot. In a car without a steering wheel or pedals, a person does not operate the brakes directly; the vehicle issues braking commands electronically.
The existing rules make it difficult to assess vehicles of this kind. In June, NHTSA announced a proposed amendment to address the issue. It would adjust requirements related to manual brake controls for vehicles designed to operate without a human driver.
Importantly, removing the brake pedal would not mean relaxing braking performance requirements. NHTSA said it would retain key performance standards, including stopping distances. Whether a person presses the brake with their foot or a computer issues the braking command may change. The safety requirement that the car stop within a specified distance in a dangerous situation would remain.
The same applies to turn signals, rear visibility and occupant protection systems. Provisions written with human drivers in mind need to be reviewed to fit new vehicle designs. The eight safety standards from which Zoox received exemptions include provisions on braking systems, as well as lighting, rear visibility, glazing and occupant crash protection.
The U.S. government did not give Zoox blanket permission to ignore all safety standards. Instead, it exempted the company from specific requirements while demanding an equivalent level of safety and imposing separate oversight conditions.
◆ Zoox gets approval, while Tesla faces an investigation over the same kind of car

The cases of Zoox and Tesla illustrate an important difference in U.S. regulation of autonomous vehicles. Zoox applied for exemptions from requirements that were difficult to apply to its vehicle. After reviewing the relevant materials, NHTSA allowed commercial operation on a limited scale. It restricted the number of vehicles and the duration of the exemptions, and imposed additional oversight conditions.
Tesla chose a different approach. It self-certified that the Cybercab meets the federal motor vehicle safety standards applicable to it. In the United States, automakers certify for themselves that their vehicles comply with applicable safety standards. Regulators can subsequently use investigations and oversight to verify whether the certification is valid.
On September 4, NHTSA announced that it had opened an investigation into Tesla’s self-certification of the Cybercab. The agency is reviewing how a vehicle without conventional driving controls such as a steering wheel and pedals could meet existing safety standards. Opening an investigation does not establish that Tesla violated the law. Regulators are reviewing technical materials on the vehicle’s design and how the safety standards were applied.
The two cases show that cars without steering wheels have become a reality, even as the relevant regulations and certification procedures continue to evolve.
◆ If police tell the car to move, who will make it move?

The challenges facing cars without steering wheels are not limited to the performance of the vehicles themselves. On the road, cars must respond not only to other drivers but also to instructions from police, firefighters and road workers. When an accident occurs, they need to make way for emergency vehicles. In construction zones, they may have to follow temporary lanes that differ from the usual road layout.
Human drivers assess the situation on the spot. Driverless cars must understand it using sensors and software. But what happens if the system cannot interpret the situation? Autonomous vehicle companies operate remote assistance and emergency response systems. When a vehicle encounters a complex situation, a remote operator can check information about the surroundings and help it proceed safely.
Remote assistance does not necessarily mean that a person directly controls the car. Depending on the company and system, a remote operator may provide route information, ask the vehicle to stop or intervene in other ways. A loss of communications must also be taken into account. A vehicle must not stop dangerously in the middle of the road or become uncontrollable simply because it has lost its connection to the control center.
A car must be able to move itself into a safe state in response to communications failures and major system malfunctions. That is why, in driverless autonomous technology, the ability to stop operating is considered just as important as the ability to drive normally.
◆ South Korea is beginning to prepare, too
The South Korean government is also working to define safety requirements for vehicles operating without drivers. In July, the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport drew up guidelines for the safe operation of driverless autonomous vehicles. They set out key safety requirements that a vehicle must meet to receive a temporary operating permit without a driver.
The guidelines require at least 15,000 kilometers of test driving. They also set a target of no more than one instance of test-driver intervention, on average, per 160 kilometers. Vehicles using the same autonomous driving system can combine their mileage if they meet certain conditions.
A remote monitoring system is also required. The control center must monitor the vehicle’s operation in real time and assist with necessary measures, such as stopping the vehicle in an emergency. Passengers must also have a way to request an emergency stop. The requirements include emergency braking that operates separately from the autonomous driving system, as well as redundant safety design to address failures of key components.
The guidelines also require the vehicle to stop safely if it leaves its permitted operating area or develops a system fault. This approach assesses whether a vehicle can handle risks without a driver, rather than focusing on whether it has a steering wheel.
The guidelines currently set standards for temporary operating permits for driverless autonomous vehicles. They should not be treated as equivalent to approval to sell every vehicle to ordinary consumers.
◆ Will removing the steering wheel change who is liable for crashes?

As cars without steering wheels become more common, liability for crashes will also become an important issue. In an ordinary car crash, investigators look at whether the driver obeyed traffic laws and took necessary steps to avoid danger. When there is no driver at all, the way the cause of a crash is determined may change.
Investigators may need to determine whether the autonomous driving system failed to detect a pedestrian, issued a braking command too late or had a problem with the vehicle’s maintenance. They may also examine whether the operator properly managed the operating area and weather conditions.
Responsibility does not always fall solely on the automaker. It is determined based on the circumstances of the crash, vehicle defects, how the vehicle was operated and the laws of the relevant country. Records showing what the vehicle detected and how it responded at the time of the crash will also be important.
In a car without a driver, software, sensors and vehicle control systems become key evidence in crash investigations. As the entity operating the vehicle changes, the methods used to investigate the causes of crashes will also need to evolve.
◆ When will anyone be able to ride in one?
Developing cars without steering wheels is not a new idea. In 2014, Google unveiled an autonomous vehicle prototype without a steering wheel or pedals. At the time, it was an experimental vehicle intended for test runs.
Waymo, which grew out of Google’s autonomous driving project, later used modified production cars. Major robotaxis currently in operation still have steering wheels and pedals. General Motors also developed the driverless Origin shuttle, but halted its development plans in 2024.
Building a car without a steering wheel does not guarantee commercial success. Companies must meet a range of requirements, including vehicle manufacturing costs, operating areas, maintenance systems, passenger demand and safety certification.
This year has brought a different kind of change. Zoox received a U.S. government exemption from safety standards for commercial operation, while Tesla put its Cybercab on public roads. Cars without steering wheels have moved out of the laboratory and into commercial operation.
The challenge ahead is to prove their safety while expanding the areas in which they can operate. Driving on a familiar road in clear weather is one thing; handling complex traffic on an unfamiliar road in heavy rain is another.
The fact that a car can drive itself does not mean it is ready to do without a steering wheel and pedals. It must be able to stop safely and protect its passengers even when no person can intervene.
What remains to be demonstrated is that these cars are safe without a steering wheel.